Papa's Menu and Specials

ATM on Site - Cash Only, Please!




Of course we offer all kinds of pizza (also known as tomato pie. *) A small plain is $13; a large plain is $14. For fresh garlic, peppers, onions, or extra tomato add $1.00, and for other toppings, such as sausage, mushrooms, pepperoni, meatballs, olives, broccoli, spinach, ricotta, hot peppers, anchovies, roasted red peppers or extra cheese, add $2.00. Or try our unique Mustard Pie (**) for $14.00 small, $15.00 large. Pizza rolls are $3.00.





We offer Pasta Fagiole $3.00 and salads: a small house salad (lettuce, tomato & beets with oil & vinegar) for $3.00, antipasto (lettuce, tomato, salami, provolone, beets and hard boiled egg with oil & vinegar) $4.50 for small; $7.50 for large, Caesar Salad ($4.50 for small; $6.50 for large), Caprese salad (mozzarella, tomato, & basil) for $6.00; and an option of adding grilled chicken to any salad ($2.75.)



Choose a sandwich ($4.50 - $6.00) for steak, cheese steak, chicken cheese steak, buffalo chicken cheese steak, sausage, meatball, meatball parmesan, hamburger, pork roll and cheese. 

We also offer three types of grilled chicken sandwich -  grilled chicken with lettuce and tomato; with broccoli rabe and provolone; or Caesar. 

All sandwiches are offered with optional toppings of peppers, onions, mushrooms, lettuce, cheese and tomato at .50 each. Fries are $3.00; cheese fries $4.00; mozzarella or zucchini sticks are $6.00. Buffalo wings with bleu cheese & celery is $9.00. Chicken fingers with french fries are $8.00, perfect for the kids.


Try a cheese steak hoagie wrap: a grilled chicken wrap with broccoli rabe & provolone; a chicken Caesar wrap;  a veggie wrap with roasted peppers, spinach, eggplant and tomato; or a Buffalo chicken cheese steak wrap  - priced at $6.00 - $6.50 each.



Our pasta choices are spaghetti, rigatoni, ravioli, cavatelli and gnocchi offered with meatballs or sausage ($9.50 - $12.00). Cavatelli is also available with sauteed broccoli rabe and sausage ($12.00.)



 Fountain soda choices include Trenton favorite, Red Cream, plus RC Cola, 7-Up, Diet-Rite or Birch Beer ($1.75 glass; $6.00 pitcher), as well as coffee and hot tea ($2.00), bottled water ($1.00) or imported Italian water ($2.00.) Or better yet, bring a bottle of wine to enjoy with dinner!


Papa's is known for high quality, reasonable prices, generous portions, and friendly atmosphere. We are here to satisfy you, and keep you coming back again and again!


*Tomato Pie versus Pizza:

There are those who say that the Trenton speciality known as Tomato Pie has a thinner, crisper crust, with the cheese sparingly put on the crust before the sauce, whereas a pizza has a  thicker crust with sauce first, then plentiful cheese on top.  Nick Azzaro says that sign makers charged by the letter, and "PIZZA" is five letters shorter than "TOMATO PIES".




**Mustard Pie is another local delicacy. Mustard is put into the dough before the pie is baked, some people love it and others don't get it. Why don't you be the judge?

Here is blog entry from "" about Papa's, and Trenton mustard pies:


 Become a Fan of Papa's on Facebook!


Home       About Us      The Oldest!      Menu


Picture Gallery    Reviews    Directions     Links




After 4 PM



Eggplant Parmigiana with Side of Rigatoni $10.00



Baked Cheese Manicotti or Chicken Marsala $10.00


Chicken Parmigiana with Side of Rigatoni  $10.00


Vodka Rigatoni or Chicken Francese $10.00



Spaghetti with Crab Sauce $11.00


Chicken Cacciatore $10.00 




Make a Free Website with Yola.