What People Are Saying
“While it's not easy to live in the shadow of New York pizza, New Jersey pies hold their own thanks in no small part to Papa's Tomato Pies.”
– Huffpost Taste
The 16 Best Pizza Shops in America, 2015
“History and nostalgia, along with the special name, enhance the mystique of this, let’s face it, pizza.”
– NY Times
Putting Tomatoes First, by Putting Them On Last, 2014
“while the neighborhood might have changed, Trenton’s remaining pie makers agree there is little chance tomato pies will disappear.”
– Jill P. Capuzzo in New Jersey Monthly
The Original, 1 /12 /2010
“…drove out of our way to finally try a bucket list pizza place. BUCKET LIST.”
– Dave Portnoy
Barstool Pizza Review, 11 /15 /2019
Featuring Shows.
Our famous Mustard Pie has gotten food vloggers and pie lovers alike to come and try it for themselves!
We Were Also Featured In…
Papa's Tomato Pies of Trenton challenges NYC shop for a place in pizza history
— Times of Trenton
Barstool Sports guy goes to Papa's and DeLorenzo's and gives them a score of ... (JEFF EDELSTEIN COLUMN)
— The Trentonian
Some of the best reviews, though, are on Papa's Facebook page, from happy customers. Some people describe the experience in words, but others find it more descriptive to post their pizza photos!